Email Us
Seamark ZM Technology Co., Ltd.

BGA X-Ray Inspection Acceptance Criteria: How to Identify Voids, Bridges and Open Joints

Table of Content [Hide]

    Ball grid array packages provide a high number of electrical connections within a compact area, but their solder joints are hidden beneath the component. Because these joints cannot be checked through normal visual inspection, BGA X-ray inspection is widely used in PCB assembly, failure analysis and post-rework verification.

    X-ray images reveal differences in material density, helping inspectors identify voids, solder bridges, open joints, insufficient solder and other hidden abnormalities. However, an unusual image does not automatically mean that a PCB must be rejected. Reliable decisions require product-specific acceptance criteria, process knowledge and suitable inspection equipment.


    What Can BGA X-Ray Inspection Detect?

    An X-ray BGA inspection system can help identify:

    • Voids inside solder joints

    • Solder bridges between adjacent balls

    • Missing or incomplete joints

    • Uneven solder-ball shapes

    • Package misalignment

    • Excess or insufficient solder

    • Head-in-pillow defects

    • PCB or package warpage indicators

    The inspection result depends on detector resolution, magnification, viewing angle, sample thickness and operator experience.

    For engineering analysis, sampling inspection and failure investigation, manufacturers can use an offline X-ray inspection machine. Offline systems allow operators to adjust magnification, angle and imaging parameters when examining suspicious solder joints.


    How Voids Appear in BGA Solder Joints

    A solder void is an empty area trapped inside a solder joint. Because the void is less dense than solder, it normally appears as a lighter region within the darker solder-ball image.

    Common causes include:

    • Moisture or contamination

    • Volatile materials escaping from solder paste

    • Incorrect reflow profiles

    • Oxidized pads or component surfaces

    • Poor solder-paste storage

    • Via-in-pad structures

    • Unsuitable flux chemistry

    The presence of a void alone does not determine whether a joint is acceptable. Inspectors should also evaluate its size, number, position and distribution.

    A small central void may have a different reliability impact from a void located near the package or PCB interface. Therefore, factories should avoid using one universal void percentage for every product.

    A useful inspection record should include the component reference, solder-joint position, void area, void location, inspection method and final decision.


    How to Identify Solder Bridges

    A solder bridge occurs when solder creates an unintended electrical connection between adjacent joints. In an X-ray image, two solder balls may appear connected by a dark path, or the normal separation between them may disappear.

    Possible causes include:

    • Excessive solder paste

    • Incorrect stencil design

    • Package misalignment

    • PCB warpage

    • Component movement during reflow

    • Excessive solder-ball collapse

    Inspectors should compare suspicious joints with the surrounding BGA pattern. Normal joints usually have consistent spacing, size and shape.

    However, copper traces, vias or components on the opposite side of the PCB may overlap in a two-dimensional image. Changing the viewing angle can help determine whether the dark region is a real solder bridge or an overlapping internal structure.

    For complex assemblies, an industrial microfocus X-ray 3D/CT machine can separate structures by depth. This is particularly useful for double-sided PCBs, power modules, advanced semiconductor packages and multilayer assemblies.


    How Open Joints Appear

    An open joint occurs when the solder ball fails to form a complete connection with the PCB pad. This may result from:

    • Package or PCB warpage

    • Insufficient solder paste

    • Contaminated pads

    • Uneven heating

    • Incorrect placement height

    • Poor component coplanarity

    Open joints are difficult to identify in a standard top-down image because the solder ball may still overlap the pad. Inspectors should look for indirect signs, including unusual ball size, inconsistent grayscale, irregular shape or repeated abnormalities near package corners.

    Tilted-angle inspection often provides more useful information than a single vertical image. Electrical testing, 3D CT or cross-section analysis may still be necessary when the result is inconclusive.


    What Is a Head-in-Pillow Defect?

    A head-in-pillow defect occurs when the BGA solder ball and solder paste melt but fail to form a complete metallurgical bond. The surfaces may appear to touch while remaining partially separated.

    Typical causes include:

    • Package warpage

    • Oxidation

    • Insufficient flux activity

    • Poor solder-paste transfer

    • Unsuitable temperature profiles

    • Uneven board support

    Because the solder ball may still appear in the correct position, this defect can be difficult to confirm through a top-down image. Tilted X-ray inspection, CT reconstruction, electrical testing or destructive analysis may be required.


    When 2D X-Ray Is Not Enough

    Two-dimensional X-ray inspection is fast and effective for many routine checks, but it compresses all internal structures into one image.

    This can create uncertainty when inspecting:

    • Double-sided PCB assemblies

    • Package-on-package devices

    • Dense multilayer boards

    • Power modules

    • Overlapping electronic components

    A practical inspection process should begin with a top-down image, followed by comparison with neighboring joints and tilted-angle inspection. If the defect still cannot be confirmed, 3D CT may be required to separate internal structures.


    Acceptance Criteria Should Match the Product

    Acceptance requirements should be based on:

    • Applicable IPC standards

    • Customer specifications

    • Product reliability requirements

    • Component-manufacturer guidance

    • Internal process capability

    • Historical failure data

    A consumer electronics board may not have the same acceptance limits as an automotive, medical or aerospace assembly.

    Manufacturers may also establish internal warning limits that are stricter than final rejection limits. This helps identify process drift before products become nonconforming.


    What to Do After Detecting a Defect

    The purpose of x ray solder joint inspection is not only to identify defects but also to guide corrective action.

    First, inspectors should confirm the indication by changing the angle or imaging settings. They should then review solder-paste records, placement data, reflow profiles and material information.

    If rework is required, a controlled BGA rework station can support component removal, site preparation, optical alignment, replacement and controlled heating. The temperature profile must be developed for the specific PCB, component and solder alloy.

    After rework, the assembly should be inspected again to verify that the original defect has been removed and that no new bridges, voids or open joints have been introduced.

    FAQs

    Can X-ray inspection detect every BGA defect?

    No. Some interface defects may require tilted imaging, 3D CT, electrical testing or cross-section analysis.

    Does every solder void require rejection?

    No. Void size, location, product class and customer requirements must all be considered.

    Can AOI replace BGA X-ray inspection?

    No. AOI checks visible features, while X-ray inspection evaluates hidden solder joints beneath the BGA package.

    When is 3D CT necessary?

    3D CT is useful when structures overlap in a 2D image or when the exact depth and shape of a defect must be confirmed.


    References
    Related News
    Leave a Message
    Resources Products
    F3, Building 11, Longwangmiao Industrial Zone, Baishixia Community, Fuyong, Bao'an, Shenzhen
    jackie@zhuomao.com.cn
    0086-0755-29929955
    We use cookies to offer you a better browsing experience, analyze site traffic and personalize content. By using this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Visit our cookie policy to learn more.
    Reject Accept